Fate (the Cosmic Chain of Causes)
Heimarmene — the unbroken chain of cause linking every event to every other, so that nothing in the universe happens by accident.
Heimarmene, or Fate, was the Stoic doctrine that the universe operates as an unbroken chain of causes stretching from the beginning of time to the end. The Stoics, particularly Chrysippus, argued that every event flows necessarily from prior events according to divine reason or logos. This is not blind chance but rational necessity woven into the fabric of reality itself. Nothing happens outside this causal sequence, and the chain cannot be interrupted or violated.
The practical consequence of heimarmene for human life was the Stoic virtue of acceptance. If all events follow from an eternal causal order, a wise person cannot wish for things to be otherwise, but can only choose their response to circumstances. This doctrine famously created tension with the question of human free will and moral responsibility—how can we be held accountable for actions if they are fated?—a problem Chrysippus and later Stoics grappled with throughout their writings.
Where this idea shows up
134 Greek sources·1 Jewish-canon citationWhere to read it
- Epigrams700 BCEPseudo-Homer· Ios
- Works and Days650 BCEHesiod· Ascra
- Shield of Heracles575 BCEPseudo-Hesiod· Ascra
- Seven Against Thebes467 BCEAeschylus· Athens
- Prometheus Bound456 BCEAeschylus· Athens
- The Second Tetralogy411 BCEAntiphon· Athens
- On the Choreutes411 BCEAntiphon· Athens
- Funeral Oration380 BCELysias· Athens
- Cyropaedia354 BCEXenophon· Athens
- Exordia349 BCEDemosthenes· Athens
- Against Timarchus346 BCEAeschines· Athens
- Epinomis345 BCEPhilip of Opus· Athens
- On the Estate of Astyphilus340 BCEIsaeus· Athens
- To Demonicus338 BCEIsocrates· Athens
- Against Ctesiphon330 BCEAeschines· Athens
- Funeral Oration322 BCEHyperides· Athens
- De interpretatione322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- Metaphysics322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- Letters322 BCEDemosthenes· Athens
- In C. Verrem70 BCECicero· Formiae
- In Catilinam63 BCECicero· Formiae
- De Rerum Natura55 BCELucretius· Rome
- De Republica54 BCECicero· Formiae
- Gallic War51 BCEJulius Caesar· Rome
- de Natura Deorum43 BCECicero· Formiae
- Ab urbe condita27 BCELivy· Padua
- Ars Amatoria1 BCEOvid· Tomis (Constanța)
- Metamorphoses8 CEOvid· Tomis (Constanța)
- Institutio Oratoria95 CEQuintilian· Rome
- Aemilius Paulus95 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Discourses108 CEEpictetus· Nicopolis
- De fortuna Romanorum120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- De fortuna120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- De Genio Socratis120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- De Sera Numinis Vindicta120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Quaestiones Convivales120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- De Defectu Oraculorum120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- De Pythiae oraculis120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Apophthegmata Laconica120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Philopoemen120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Consolatio ad Apollonium120 CEPseudo-Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Parallela minora120 CEPseudo-Plutarch· Chaeronea
- De Fato120 CEPseudo-Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Divus Julius122 CESuetonius· Rome
- Divus Augustus122 CESuetonius· Rome
- Divus Vespasianus122 CESuetonius· Rome
- Divus Titus122 CESuetonius· Rome
- Domitianus122 CESuetonius· Rome
- The Handbook135 CEEpictetus· Nicopolis
- Syrian Wars165 CEAppian of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Civil Wars165 CEAppian of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Macedonian Affairs165 CEAppian of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Punic Wars165 CEAppian of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Ad Se Ipsum170 CEMarcus Aurelius· Vindobona (Vienna)
- Vitarum auctio180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Lucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Dialogi mortuorum180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Juppiter Confutatus180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Cataplus180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Noctes Atticae180 CEAulus Gellius· Rome
- De astrologia180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Saturnalia180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Dialogi deorum180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Deorum concilium180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Lucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Dialogi Marini180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Hermotimus180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Apologia180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Juppiter Tragoedus180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Demonax180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Necyomantia180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Contemplantes180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Alexander180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Deipnosophistae230 CEAthenaeus of Naucratis· Naucratis
- Res Gestae400 CEAmmianus Marcellinus· Rome
- Boethius· Rome
- Ibn Ezra on Exodus1145 CE