Argument by Example
"Remember what happened last time": arguing from a parallel case is rhetoric's version of induction, the persuasive cousin of the logician's proof.
The *paradeigma* or argument by example is a rhetorical technique of persuasion through particular cases. Unlike logical induction in dialectic, which builds a universal rule from multiple instances, rhetorical example works more directly: it presents one or more concrete cases and invites the audience to recognize a similar pattern in the matter at hand. Aristotle treats it as a form of inductive reasoning distinct from the enthymeme, suited to audiences who grasp resemblance more readily than formal deduction.
In practice, an orator arguing that a treaty will be broken might cite historical precedents—how other rulers violated similar agreements in the past—without spelling out a logical chain. The listener perceives the likeness between those prior cases and the present situation and draws the conclusion themselves. This sideways reasoning, part-to-part and like-to-like within a common category, proved especially effective in court and assembly speeches where emotional conviction mattered as much as abstract proof.
Where this idea shows up
30 Greek sourcesWhere to read it
- Fragments & Testimonia345 BCEAristotle· Athens
- On the False Embassy343 BCEDemosthenes· Athens
- To Demonicus338 BCEIsocrates· Athens
- The Funeral Speech338 BCEDemosthenes· Athens
- On the Crown330 BCEDemosthenes· Athens
- Analytica priora322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- Problemata322 BCEPseudo-Aristotle· Chalcis
- De Inventione84 BCECicero· Formiae
- In C. Verrem70 BCECicero· Formiae
- Pro A. Cluentio66 BCECicero· Formiae
- Pro Archia Poeta62 BCECicero· Formiae
- Partitiones Oratoriae43 BCECicero· Formiae
- Ab urbe condita27 BCELivy· Padua
- Institutio Oratoria95 CEQuintilian· Rome
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Demosthenes120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Consolatio ad Apollonium120 CEPseudo-Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Punic Wars165 CEAppian of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Lucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Pro imaginibus180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Harmonides180 CELucian of Samosata· Samosata
- Adversus Mathematicos190 CESextus Empiricus· Alexandria