Place & Space
Where is a thing? Aristotle's answer: its place is the inner surface of whatever immediately surrounds it — not an empty box it sits inside.
Aristotle developed the concept of topos, or place, as the innermost boundary of the body that contains something. Rather than thinking of place as empty space waiting to be filled, Aristotle argued that place is the surface of the containing vessel itself—the wall of the cup holds the wine's place, not some invisible container around it. This definition was meant to explain how objects can move from place to place while maintaining their identity and how we locate things in the physical world.
The practical consequence of this view shapes how we understand spatial relationships. When we say two things are "together in place," Aristotle means they share the same boundary; when they are separate, they occupy different enclosing surfaces. This became the dominant framework for ancient physics and influenced medieval and early modern thinking about space, even as later philosophers like Sextus Empiricus raised logical problems with whether a containing surface can truly serve as a thing's place without contradiction.
Where this idea shows up
34 Greek sources·2 Jewish-canon citationsWhere to read it
- Fragments & Testimonia345 BCEAristotle· Athens
- Meteorologica322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- Metaphysics322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- De animalium incessu322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- Nicomachean Ethics322 BCEAristotle· Chalcis
- Problemata322 BCEPseudo-Aristotle· Chalcis
- On the Causes of Plants287 BCETheophrastus· Athens
- Fragmenta varia287 BCETheophrastus· Athens
- De Ventis287 BCETheophrastus· Athens
- Phaenomena265 BCEEuclid· Alexandria
- Pro A. Caecina69 BCECicero· Formiae
- De Rerum Natura55 BCELucretius· Rome
- Tusculanae Disputationes43 BCECicero· Formiae
- Institutio Oratoria95 CEQuintilian· Rome
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- De Defectu Oraculorum120 CEPlutarch· Chaeronea
- Plutarch· Chaeronea
- Mithridatic Wars165 CEAppian of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Noctes Atticae180 CEAulus Gellius· Rome
- Adversus Mathematicos190 CESextus Empiricus· Alexandria
- Pyrrhoniae Hypotyposes210 CESextus Empiricus· Alexandria
- Theon of Alexandria· Alexandria
- Res Gestae400 CEAmmianus Marcellinus· Rome
- Ohr Hashem1399 CE
- Sefer HaIkkarim1425 CE